New York Yankees vs Philadelphia Phillies Prediction, Odds & Expert MLB Pick – 24.07.26
New York Yankees
C. Schlittler
Philadelphia Phillies
J. Luzardo
Match Winner
Total Runs
Tale of the Tape
NYY
Key Matchup: Starting Pitchers
C. Schlittler
J. Luzardo
Detailed Analysis
Who will win today? New York Yankees vs Philadelphia Phillies MLB Preview
The New York Yankees will secure the win because C. Schlittler is pitching lights out right now while the Philadelphia Phillies are fading after a demoralizing blowout loss. The eye test shows a Philly squad that looks sluggish in the dugout, and they simply don’t have the arms to match the Bronx Bombers’ league-leading staff.
The Starter Showdown: C. Schlittler vs J. Luzardo
C. Schlittler has been absolute nails this season, sporting a dominant 2.20 ERA that anchors the best pitching staff in baseball. He has the “it” factor right now, consistently finding the zone and keeping hitters off-balance with high-velocity junk.
On the bump for the home team, J. Luzardo carries a respectable 3.43 ERA, but he is prone to shelling if he can’t command his secondary pitches early. While he’s a gamer, the Philadelphia Phillies team pitching ranks #19th with a 4.27 ERA, which doesn’t inspire much confidence against a disciplined lineup.
Offensive Trends & Lineup Depth
Both teams are scuffling for contact with identical .236 AVG marks, but the New York Yankees are much better at small ball and situational hitting. They’ve manufactured 480 Runs (Rank #10th) this year, proving they can cross the plate even when they aren’t racking up Hits (795, Rank #27th).
The Philadelphia Phillies are coming off a rough 5-9 loss where their bullpen was taxed, leaving them vulnerable in high-leverage spots tonight. With the short porch at Citizens Bank Park, travel fatigue could play a major role for a Philly defense that has already coughed up 50 Errors this season.
Looking for more action? See our More MLB Picks.
Our Final Verdict
The New York Yankees have the clear Pitching Advantage and the momentum of a shutout win in their last outing. Between C. Schlittler‘s dominance and a Philly bullpen that is running on fumes, the road team has the grit to grind out a victory in this tough environment.

vs

Pick to Win: New York Yankees
Total Runs (Over/Under): over (Line: 8)
Last 5 Games: NYY
| Opponent | Result |
|---|---|
| vs PIT | W 2-0 |
| vs PIT | L 3-5 |
| vs PIT | L 0-0 |
| vs PIT | W 8-5 |
| vs LAD | W 2-1 |
Last 5 Games: PHI
| Opponent | Result |
|---|---|
| vs LAD | L 5-9 |
| vs LAD | L 1-2 |
| vs LAD | W 10-7 |
| vs NYM | L 1-6 |
| vs NYM | W 6-1 |
Key Questions About Today’s Game
Which team has the edge in New York Yankees vs Philadelphia Phillies?
Fade the public if you want, but we like New York Yankees in this one. The season record backs it up.
What’s the run total set at for tonight?
The total is posted at 8. We’re leaning over given the pitching matchup and both teams’ recent scoring trends.
Always make sure to check when New York Yankees vs Philadelphia Phillies gets underway.
Gates open early, but first pitch is set for 10:40 PM ET at Citizens Bank Park, Philadelphia.
This analysis was prepared by the PicksMuse MLB Editorial Team, tracking season-long ATS records across all 30 MLB teams. All stats sourced from official MLB data feeds.
Written by Matt Dorsey
Matt Dorsey turned his obsession with sports into a career five years ago, and he hasn't looked back. By combining a fan's passion with a veteran’s analytical eye, Matt provides reliable insights for the NBA, NHL, and NFL. He knows you’re looking for more than just a pick; you’re looking for a reason to trust the play. That’s why his work is always transparent, researched, and rooted in five years of proven results.
More MLB Action Today
Colorado Rockies
Milwaukee Brewers
Chicago Cubs
Pittsburgh Pirates
Kansas City Royals
Detroit Tigers
Arizona Diamondbacks
Washington Nationals
Atlanta Braves
Baltimore Orioles
Cleveland Guardians
Tampa Bay Rays